Stem cell research a moral

In earlyNew Jersey became the first state to invest in stem cell research. Adult blood stem cells Adult stem cells occur in many tissues and can differentiate into specialized cells in their tissue of origin and also transdifferentiate into specialized cells characteristic of other tissues.

Cambridge University Press, 65—75 Lee, P.

Ethical Issues in Stem Cell Research

But some supporters of the research also argue against the creation of embryos for the sole purpose of harvesting cells and then destroying them. It uses the same technology as somatic cell nuclear transfer, with a preemptive alteration. This kind of stem cell bank would require the creation of embryos from gamete donors who share the same HLA-types i.

However, their spirituality is often not grounded in a strong sense of transcendence and divine givens. How we put "our world" together invariably determines which moral principles or virtues we espouse and which ones we reject. However, some question whether this distinction is viable, especially in the HESC research context.

National Academies Press Ethical and policy issues in research involving human participants. Other donors may object to their cells being injected into animals. It is a reality that will not only affect the outcome of this debate, but of numerous moral quandaries in the days ahead.

Evidence of safety and proof of principle should be established through appropriate preclinical studies in relevant animal models or through human studies of similar cell-based interventions. Utilitarianism flows from the naturalistic side of this worldview and compassion from its spiritualistic side.

Over the next two years, Connecticut, Illinois, Maryland, New York and Wisconsin joined the list of states making a commitment to fund stem cell research. Participants in cancer clinical trials commonly expect that they will benefit personally from the trial, although the primary purpose of phase I trials is to test safety rather than efficacy Dilemmas occur when donors of research oocytes receive payments in excess of their expenses and such payments are not permitted in the jurisdiction where the hSC cells will be used.

If you think of a living being as an integrated unit or complete system, ANT would break the system into subsets and study only a subsystem. Oliver O'Donovan of Oxford University rightly reminds us that the virtue of compassion can never stand alone.

Contrasting their ethical system with the prevailing "principle ethics" of the day, people like Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill argued that the foundation for ethics was consequences of a particular kind: Utilitarianism purports to rely upon an amoral criterion in weighing the consequences of human action, but happiness is hardly an amoral criterion.

In California, CIRM has instituted heightened requirements for informed consent for oocyte donation for research So we have to break the problem into parts that are not themselves units of moral concern. However, when set apart from the moral givens of a loving, gracious Creator, compassion will lead us to the abyss of moral nihilism.

For the Catholic Church and many other Christian groups, life begins at conception, making the research tantamount to homicide because it results in the destruction of human embryos.

Stem-Cell Research: Setting the Moral Frame

In the case of embryos that are naturally conceived, they must implant, receive nourishment, and avoid exposure to dangerous substances in utero. It assumes an objectivity in making this assessment. The vast majority of scientific experts, including the Director of the NIH under President Bush, believe that a lack of access to new embryonic stem cell lines hinders progress toward stem cell-based transplantation 8.

Cord blood stem cells Hematopoietic stem cells from cord blood can be banked and are widely used for allogenic and autologous stem cell transplantation in pediatric hematological diseases as an alternative to bone marrow transplantation. There is merely a quantitative difference between the mental capacities of embryos, fetuses, infants, children, and adults as well as among infants, children, and adults.

Stem cell controversy

Thus researchers in clinical trials of hESC transplantation should inform eligible participants that transplanted materials originated from human embryos. If we listen closely to the moral discourse arguing that embryonic stem cells should be employed in medical research, we get a glimpse into the prevailing moral culture of our time.

Other religious groups do not take a position on the issue, and some, including many Jewish and more-liberal Christian groups, support embryonic stem cell research.

Stem Cell Research at the Crossroads of Religion and Politics

Opponents of embryonic stem cell research object to two basic techniques: The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare. While appeals to compassion are becoming increasingly common in public debate, regarding compassion as the moral trump card is problematic.

Different religious groups hold a wide variety of opinions on embryonic stem cell research.Stem Cell Research In the midst of the debate over using embryonic stem cells in research, a more fundamental issue has often been overlooked.

It is a reality that will not only affect the outcome of this debate, but of numerous moral quandaries in the days ahead. In the midst of the debate over using embryonic stem cells in research, a more fundamental issue has often been overlooked. It is a reality that will not only affect the outcome of this debate, but of numerous moral quandaries in the days ahead.

Aug 09,  · Embryonic stem cell research, which uses special cells found in three- to five-day-old human embryos to seek cures for a host of chronic diseases, has sparked a major moral and political debate in the United States.

Watch video · In the case of embryonic stem cell research, it is impossible to respect both moral slcbrand.com obtain embryonic stem cells, the early embryo has to be destroyed. This means destroying a potential human life. But embryonic stem cell research could lead to the discovery of new medical treatments that would alleviate the suffering of many people.

Stem Cell Research at the Crossroads of Religion and Politics

American Life League has amassed thousands of documents and articles on the full spectrum of life issues. We are also actively creating and promoting new media resources, bringing essential knowledge of the pro-life movement to a new generation.

How to use this resource section: To the left of your screen, you’ll find educational topics related [ ]. Apr 14,  · Because of these restrictions on NIH funding, a number of states have established programs to fund stem cell research, including the derivation of new embryonic stem cell lines.

Ethics of Stem Cell Research

California, for example, has allocated $3 billion over 10 yr to stem cell research.

Download
Stem cell research a moral
Rated 5/5 based on 16 review